pickup icon

Our website is pick-up only during the hotter months. For warm weather shipments, please call the store during working hours (Tues through Sat 10-6) at 815-758-5990 to get a shipping quote. Please see our shipping policy at the bottom of this page to get a general idea of shipping costs during the summertime.

Mustache Nutter Butter
Mustache Nutter Butter

Mustache Nutter Butter

Regular price
$1.95
Sale price
$1.95

Dad's love Nutter Butter Cookies with chocolate, so adding a mustache is next-level goodness! Each Mustache Nutter Butter is wrapped in a clear bag with a sparkly stribbon.